MEV, a Relay Flaw and an Acquittal: What the Peraire-Bueno Case Means for Ethereum Staking

As reported on November 19, 2026, a U.S. federal judge had acquitted Anton and James Peraire-Bueno over a 2023 Ethereum transaction-reordering scheme. The November 16 ruling turned on a narrow question: what false representation, if any, had the brothers made? It did not decide that every form of maximal extractable value (MEV) is lawful.

The distinction matters beyond this case. BlackRock’s March 2026 prospectus for its iShares Staked Ethereum Trust ETF identifies MEV as a potential source of staking revenue—and warns that a finding that MEV violates applicable law could disrupt its staking arrangements.

How the disputed block was built

MEV is value obtained by controlling whether transactions enter a block and in what order. One contested strategy is a sandwich: a bot buys before another trader’s transaction and sells afterward, potentially leaving that trader with a worse execution price. The three traders described as victims in this case operated bots seeking such opportunities.

According to the court record, the brothers studied those bots, set up 16 validators and, when one of their validators was due to propose a block on April 2, 2023, placed eight bait transactions in the public pending-transaction pool. The bots submitted transaction sequences intended to sandwich the bait.

The brothers then exploited a flaw in the Ultrasound relay’s checks. A relay normally gives a validator a block header to sign before revealing the full transaction list. Here, the brothers signed a header with zero values in two fields that should have identified the parent block and prior state. The relay verified that the signature came from the scheduled validator but did not verify those field values before releasing the transactions. Ethereum nodes rejected the invalid block; the brothers could then use the revealed ordering to propose a different, valid block that retained the bots’ purchases but prevented their planned sales.

Prosecutors described the scheme as obtaining about $25 million in roughly 12 seconds. That figure and framing came from the prosecution, not an independent civil accounting of each loss by the judge.

MEV, a Relay Flaw and an Acquittal: What the Peraire-Bueno Case Means for Ethereum Staking

What the ruling did—and did not—resolve

Prosecutors argued that the bait transactions implied they would execute as the bots expected, and that signing a block header promised publication of the corresponding block. The judge rejected both theories: a pending transaction did not promise anyone a sandwich opportunity, and the signature identified the validator without guaranteeing that the block was valid or would reach the chain. The relay operator acknowledged that its failure to check the fields was a software error.

The brothers had been charged in May 2024 with wire fraud, conspiracy to commit wire fraud and conspiracy to commit money laundering. A 2025 jury trial ended without a unanimous verdict. After a trial without a jury, the judge acquitted them on November 16, 2026, finding that the alleged concealment and exploitation of the flaw did not establish the material misrepresentation required for the fraud charges. With the underlying fraud theory unsuccessful, the related money-laundering conspiracy charge also failed.

Why a staking prospectus mentions MEV

BlackRock’s prospectus says its staking providers may receive MEV alongside protocol rewards and transaction tips. It anticipates staking about 70%–95% of the fund’s ETH under normal conditions and says the sponsor and service chain together receive 18% of gross staking rewards, with the remainder retained by the fund.

That disclosure does not say the fund runs sandwich bots or participated in the relay exploit. Nor does the acquittal clear every MEV strategy of legal risk. The prospectus separately describes contractual obligations for validators arranged through Coinbase, including anti-money-laundering and sanctions-screening controls, while warning that failures and losses may still affect the fund and its holders.

The case illustrates a boundary between a software check, an economic incentive and a legally enforceable promise. The ruling addressed the prosecution’s proof of fraud in this transaction—not the legality or costs of transaction ordering across Ethereum.

Further reading